More Problems for Charite Artificail Disc - Lawsuits Mounting

The following story chronicals the problems that recipients of the Charite Artificial Lumbar Disc are having. Beware if your spine surgeon wants to put one in your back. Bagolie Friedman Injury Lawyers are investigating failed Charite Disc back surgery claims and offer free consultations and aggressive representation. Call toll free 1-866-333-3529 or visit our website now.



Problems Following Total Disc Replacement
03-Jan-07 -

The Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery (American). 2007;89:82-88.
doi:10.2106/JBJS.F.00432
© 2007 The Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery, Inc.

Prevalence of Heterotopic Ossification Following Total Disc Replacement
A Prospective, Randomized Study of Two Hundred and Seventy-six Patients
P. Justin Tortolani, MD1, Bryan W. Cunningham2, MMech Eng2, Paul C. McAfee, MD1, Gwen A. Holsapple, BS2 and Karen A. Adams, BS2
1 Scoliosis and Spine Center of Maryland, O'Dea Medical Arts Building, 7506 Osler Drive, Suite 104, Baltimore, MD 21204
2 Orthopaedic Research Laboratory, Union Memorial Hospital, 201 East University Parkway, Suite 781, Baltimore, MD 21218

Investigation performed at Scoliosis and Spine Center of Maryland, St. Joseph Medical Center, and the Orthopaedic Research Laboratory, Union Memorial Hospital, Baltimore, Maryland




--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Background: Despite reports of good clinical outcomes in patients treated with lumbar and cervical disc replacements, varying degrees of heterotopic bone have been observed around these devices. The purposes of the present study were to determine the prevalence of heterotopic ossification following lumbar disc replacement and to investigate whether heterotopic ossification results in loss of motion or negatively affects clinical outcome.

Methods: All preoperative and postoperative radiographs from a completed prospective, randomized, United States Food and Drug Administration-regulated trial comparing replacement with the CHARITÉ Artificial Disc with anterior interbody arthrodesis were analyzed. In each of 276 patients treated with disc replacement, heterotopic ossification was categorized with use of a validated 5-point radiographic classification system both preoperatively and at all protocol-specified follow-up intervals to two years. The range of motion on flexion and extension radiographs made preoperatively was compared with that on radiographs made two years postoperatively, and the motion was correlated with the presence or absence of heterotopic ossification. Similarly, validated clinical outcome measures were correlated with the presence or absence of heterotopic ossification at two years.

Results: The prevalence of heterotopic ossification in the 276 consecutive patients treated with lumbar disc replacement with the CHARITÉ Artificial Disc was 4.3%. There were four cases of Class-I heterotopic ossification and eight cases of Class-II heterotopic ossification. In five of the twelve patients, heterotopic bone was visible as early as six weeks postoperatively, and eleven of the twelve patients had evidence of heterotopic ossification by three months postoperatively. The postoperative range of motion exceeded the preoperative range in all of the patients with heterotopic ossification. With the numbers available, no difference in either the range of motion or the clinical outcome at twenty-four months postoperatively was found between the patients who had and those who did not have heterotopic ossification.

Conclusions: Heterotopic ossification is infrequent in patients treated with the CHARITÉ Artificial Disc, and it does not impact the range of motion or clinical outcome.

Level of Evidence: Prognostic Level II. See Instructions to Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.

Bagolie Quoted in Herald News Medical Malpractice Article

Bagolie Friedman Injury Lawyers founding partner Ricky Bagolie was recently interviewed by Betsy Querna of The Herald News for an article entiltled

When Medical Care Makes Things Worse.

Legal remedy

Many turn to the legal system for recourse, though it is often in vain. "If you see 100 cases, 99 turn out not to be something actionable or worth filing," says Ricky Bagolie, a malpractice lawyer who grew up in Clifton. "A bad result doesn't mean it was negligent or bad care."

Buchalla contacted a lawyer about filing a lawsuit for allegedly bad care. He was told nothing could be done because there was no proof of wrongdoing.

Santos Sanchez, 52, of Passaic, says he contacted several lawyers, but none would take his case. He was unhappy with a breast-reduction surgery earlier this year.

If you or a loved one has been hurt or has been a victim of medical mistake or malpractice, contact Bagolie Friedman Injury Lawyers now for a confidential and free consultation.